Home   >   Blog

Krautkramer vs. Panametrics: Comparison of Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

In this blog post, you’ll read:Do not know which ultrasonic thickness gauge supplier is right for you? The Krautkramer or the Panametrics? We compare two brands in details to help you pick the perfect one.

Table of Contents

Many quality assessment inspectors often wonder which ultrasonic thickness gauge is most suitable for inspection. The Krautkramer or the Panametrics? 

Choosing between these two brands of ultrasonic thickness gauges can be very challenging, considering they are both quality brands. But here’s the thing. Regardless of their numerous ultrasonic thickness gauge models and plenteous beneficial specifications, only one will be most suitable for your thickness measurement, and you will have to pick one.

This review aims to help you pick the most suitable ultrasonic thickness gauge brand of the two that is most suitable for your inspection. Here, we lay bare all the information about the two brands in detail, including the specifications of their most popular models. So, if you are ready, let’s dive in. 

 

I. Krautkramer Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

1. About Krautkramer

Krautkramer has been a leading supplier of non-destructive ultrasonic testing equipment, with over a century of industry experience. Who else could have thought that this trailblazing company would change leadership and name twice through the years?

After many years of manufacturing efficient quality products, the brand has become a household name in producing non-destructive testing machines. One of its noteworthy products in a line of various equipment is the ultrasonic thickness gauge.

Krautkramer was once purchased by General Electric Inspection Technologies but is now under a new leadership known as Waygate Technologies. Despite the transfer of ownership between companies, its quality has remained intact. And numerous pieces of equipment from this same brand are distributed and supplied globally.

 

2. Popular Models

 

CL5 Handheld Thickness Gauge

 

CL5 Handheld Thickness Gauge

 

The CL5 Handheld Thickness Gauge precisely measures the thickness of components such as plastic, steel, and metal. These components are usually very laborious to measure with conventional gauges. Therefore, the CL5 Handheld Thickness Gauge is the perfect tool that suits such types of measurements. 

 

  • Specifications 

 

  • Power supply – It is powered by custom rechargeable batteries or by three AA batteries (Alkaline, NiMH, or NiCad)
  • Size – 7.1 in H × 3.7 in W × 1.8 in D • (180 mm × 94 mm × 46 mm)
  • Data recorder – It is built with a 64MB storage device that serves as a programmable data Recorder and can take a maximum of 120 files.
  • Weight – With the batteries, it has a net weight of (420g) equivalent to 0.92 lb. 
  • Operating languages – Also programmed with several easy-to-understand languages such as French, Italian, Spanish, English, Russian, German, Chinese, etc., for a user-friendly experience.

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

DM5E Corrosion Thickness Gauge

 

DM5E Corrosion Thickness Gauge

 

The DM5E has the innate ability to measure precisely and give you reliable measurements even in harsh working spaces. It is also fabricated with pre-installed used probes for easy operation and functionality. All of the functions above and features assist in acquiring trusted and accurate reading.

 

  • Specifications

 

  • Suitable for measurements of storage tanks, pipelines, and pressure vessels
  • Equipped with three levels of functionality (DM5E Basic, DM5E, and DM5E DL)
  • Powered by AA batteries that allow the operation to last for up to 60 hrs.
  • Comfortably designed for a gross weight of 223g.
  • A backlit display screen for easy visibility in any lighting condition.
  • It is also equipped with a dual-multi operational function, which allows for seamless measurement of pipes through its coating with an accurate reading.
  • The DM5E DL can store up to fifty thousand data and is quite identical to the DM5E.

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

DMS Go+ Series Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

DMS Go+ Series Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

The DMS Go+ series of A-scan ultrasonic thickness gauge measures exhaustively and in numerous applications because of its user-friendly, applicable features and functionalities. And just like the DM5E series also comes in three varying but identical functions, which include the DMS Go+ Basic, DMS Go+, and the DMS Go+ Advanced.

 

  • Specifications 

 

  • It weighs approximately 850g, inclusive of the battery
  • Operation Temperature is from 0-550 c
  • Display mode includes: Thickness and A-Scan, B-Scan, Differential, Minimum and Maximum Capture, and temperature corrupted thickness.
  • Memory Storage – is typically a 16GB memory size.
  • And complies with various standard quality control and assessment protocols.
  • Calibration includes – 0ne point, two-point, Auto V=Path Correction, Auto or Manual On-Block, and off-Block Zero.
  • Power – Li-ion rechargeable battery that lasts up to 8 hours of operation.

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

II. Panametrics Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

1. About Panametrics

This is another excellent brand from another trusted company in the ultrasonic thickness gauge manufacturing industry. The Baker Hughes company has over half a century of expertise in engineering equipment for testing purposes. 

The parametric thickness gauge is one of the many devices and testing solutions that has been produced under the Baker Hughes business. This equipment’s application is deployed in numerous sectors, from structural/building inspections to agriculture and corrosion monitoring and it’s also employed by brewing companies for various tank inspections. 

With its headquarters in Massachusetts, Panametrics was founded in 1960 by Baker and Hughes, and it boasts products that are safe and clean for both the technician and the environment.

 

2. Popular Models

 

38DL PLUS® Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

38DL PLUS® Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge 

 

The 38DL Plus ultrasonic thickness gauge is a handheld tool that is applicable in many if not all types of thickness inspections. Such applications include thin or double-layered materials and wall thinning measurements with easy-to-use measurement characteristics. It is consistent with single or double element transducers, with accurate and precise readings.

 

  • Specifications 

 

  • It has a wide range of operating temperatures.
  • Adjustable backlighting for indoor and outdoor uses
  • Weighs only about 0.814kg which is equivalent to 1.80lb
  • Comes with a gauge stand and a protective rubber 
  • Rugged, reliable, and easy to use
  • Consistent with both single and dual element transducer compatibility
  • This thickness gauge can execute double-layer software measurement alternatives or even four-layer measurements.
  • The device’s features can be locked due to its password protection function.
  • It is designed with both internal and external storage features for easy operation and storage.

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

45MG Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

45MG Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

The 45MG ultrasonic thickness gauge, like the 38DL Plus, is also a handheld thickness gauge that is rugged, simple to operate, and reliable for accurate inspection data. It is also compatible with the single and dual element transducers, which makes it a vast tool for inspection as it is applicable in nearly all the applications of a thickness gauge. It is built for the brute environment but with easy-to-use features designed for effortless operation.

 

  • Specifications 

 

  • An uncomplicated keypad that enables both right- and left-hand usage.
  • A password lock protects the device. 
  • It is also designed with a USB communication channel
  • Also, with default and custom single element transducer setup.
  • It is also equipped with a broad temperature range in operation.
  • Adjustment feature between standard, high, and low.
  • It can easily become a multipurpose thickness gauge tool from a simple corrosion gauge.

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

27MG Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

27MG Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

 

The 27MG ultrasonic thickness gauge weighs about 340g. It is an economical tool that aids and assists in measuring corroded pipes and tanks or eroded surfaces with precise measurements. This is an easy one-handed operated, battery-powered device with a transflective display. It utilizes the same technologies as the other various ultrasonic thickness gauges, with an undemanding numerical keypad that enables an operator to access other features.

 

  • Specifications 

 

  • Measures thick or thin materials
  • It is applicable for numerous fundamental corrosion thickness measurements, and its dual element transducer enables this.
  • Probe recognition is automatic and enhances the performance of the transducers as it automatically recalls the V-path amendment.
  • Auto Zero compensation which optimizes the precision of gauging on hot exteriors.
  • A minimum to the maximum mode records the thickness at 20 estimations per second.
  • Also has Hi-Low settings on the alarm

 

  • Price Range 

 

 

III. Krautkramer vs. Panametrics Which is the Best for you?

 

While both brands of ultrasonic thickness gauges are great, nonetheless, parametric appears to have more benefits using the following parameters:

 

  • Types of material can be measured: The more materials an ultrasonic thickness gauge can measure, the better. Panametrics can measure a wider variety of materials, including all engineering materials like metals, plastics, composites, fiberglass, ceramics, and biological samples and liquid levels. 
  • Thickness range: The thickness range of materials measured by parametric is also very commendable. It is very beneficial to an inspector if a thickness gauge can measure thin and thick materials without needing a new set of thickness gauges. 
  • Accuracy: Panametrics also offer a higher level of accuracy when compared with what Krautkramer offers, especially for situations where unstable temperatures can significantly affect the accuracy. 
  • Durability: While both are highly durable due to their quality manufacturing, panametric can still function in harsh conditions where krautkramer cannot.
  • Price: Most importantly, the price of panametrics is slightly more affordable than krautkramer.

 

➤ Related Article: Dakota vs Cygnus: Comparison of Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge

➤ Related Article: Top 10 Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge Manufacturers

➤ Related Article: How to Choose an Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge?

 

 

IV. Your Budget Pick: NDT-KITS

  • Better Price: To acquire the best tools money can buy, a trusted supplier must be located. This is what NDT-KITS makes available on a platter, and they have been a trusted brand in the industry and one of the leading suppliers currently in the market.
  • Manufacturing Experience: NDT-KITS has over three decades of manufacturing experience. You will be latching on to their wealth of experience and credibility when you choose them as your supplier of ultrasonic thickness tools at affordable prices.
  • Brand History: When a reliable brand has been in the industry for over three decades, it becomes a household name, and with the history and experience NDT-KITS has under its belt, it is safe to say they are a household name that can be trusted.
  • SGS Supplier: NDT-KITS are top-ranked in the industry with quality certified products which allows its clients to trust them with handling a lot of their supplies.

 

Plan to buy ut thickness gauge from NDT-KITS, but do not know the process of importing ultrasonic thickness gages from China? Here’ s the guide for you: ​​How to Import Ultrasonic Thickness Gauges from China?

 

Conclusion

In conclusion, this post has established the importance of these two ultrasonic thickness gauges for inspection, especially when it involves the inspection of corroded or eroded materials.

Furthermore, it has been able to compare which ultrasonic thickness gauge is suitable for your measurements based on which tool is best for your inspection. 

Finally, when considering a reliable supplier based on brand history, manufacturing experience, and reasonable, affordable pricing as your budget allows, NDT-KITS remains your sure plug.

 

4.9/5 - (28 votes)